Nanotechnology to Cure the Breast Cancer and Obstacles in its Way

Ayesha Fazal Nawaz1*, Atiqa Riaz1, Adnan Iqbal1, Rizwan Arshad1, Shehla Shoukat2, Amir zia2

1Department of Biochemistry and Biotechnology, University of Gujrat, Gujrat, Pakistan

2National Institute of Genomics and Advanced Studies in Biotechnology, National Agriculture Research Center, Islamabad, Pakistan

*Corresponding Author:
Ayesha Fazal Nawaz
Department of Biochemistry and Biotechnology,
University of Gujrat,
Gujrat (50700),
Pakistan,
Tel No: +93167689636
E-mail: ayeshafazal387@gmail.com

Received Date: October 12, 2021; Accepted Date: October 26, 2021; Published Date: November 3, 2021

Citation: Nawaz AF, Riaz A, Iqbal A, Arshad R, Shoukat S, et al. (2021) Nanotechnology to Cure Breast Cancer and Obstacles in its Way. J Med Oncol Vol.4 No.5: 06.

Visit for more related articles at Journal of Medical Oncology

Abstract

Nanomaterials owing to their remarkable pharmaceutical properties and potential to load large quantities of drugs are considered an ideal vector for carrying medicine to the target site. The treatment of breast cancer has been a pressing issue due the use of conventional methods of treatment resulting in many side effects. Nanotechnology offers a more targeted approach in breast cancer treatment. The present review examines the role of Carbon Nanotubes (CNTs) and nanoparticles in the treatment of breast cancer and the obstacles in the way of nanotechnology in becoming one of the best methods in breast cancer treatment and drug delivery. Use of monoclonal antibody trastuzumab against HER-2 biomarkers by attaching it with nanotubes or nanoparticles is considered the best targeted therapy along with photo thermal ablation. The absence of human tumor models and lack of toxicological assays are the major factors contributing to differences between the preclinical and clinical trial results.

Keywords

Breast cancer; Doxorubicin; Gold nanoparticles; Trastuzumab; Targeted drug delivery

Introduction

Cancer is one of leading causes of death worldwide. It results from the disruption of balance between cell proliferation and cell death leading to development of abnormal cells. This imbalanced condition arises due to gene deletion, mutation, and translocation, causing genetic variation [1]. Breast cancer manifests because of abnormal growth of cells in breast tissues leading to lobular carcinoma; cancer of lobules and ductal carcinoma; cancer of ducts, both can be invasive or non-invasive. Mutations in genes like BRCA1, BRCA2, RB, PIK3, MDM2, HER2 and TPK53 result in the development of breast cancer [2]. Breast cancer is the second most commonly diagnosed cancer (11.6% of the total cases) after lung cancer and is the leading cause of cancer death in women in over 100 countries. Each year 2.1 million women are affected and in 2018, out of 2,048,849 women diagnosed with breast cancer, 626,789 died making 15% of the total cancer deaths in women. According to GLOBOCAN 2018 estimate, the age standardized (world) incidence rate (ASIR) was 43.6 and age standardized (world) mortality rate (ASMR) was 13.0 [3].

The possible factors associated with development of breast cancer include reproductive, menstrual, and hormonal factors. The family history, obesity, high caloric diet, lack of breastfeeding, use of oral contraceptive pills and ingestion of hormones like estrogen in HRT are all contributing factors to breast cancer [4,5].

Traditional treatment of breast cancer involves approaches like surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy, all of which have certain limitations and many side effects. Chemotherapy involves the use of anticancer drugs which are non-specific and cytotoxic. They target not only cancer cells but also healthy cells in the body and leads to Multiple Drug Resistance (MDR). Radiotherapy can also cause side effects due to damage to tissues surrounding the cancer site. This can also cause impairment of immune system and other side effects like fatigue, anemia, diarrhea and vomiting [1]. The use of radiation therapy is also influenced by the presence of breast cancer gene variants. Individuals having pathogenic variants of TP53 are at higher risk of development of new cancers form radiation therapy. The use of radiotherapy and chemotherapy can also cause increase risk of heart disease [6,7]. Surgery can be used for localized cancer removal but it fails in the treatment of metastasized cancer [1]. Nanotherapy on the other provides a solution to all above problems by providing targeted drug delivery to cancer cells with reduced toxicity, enhanced imaging, monitoring and effective drug delivery [8].

Carbon Nanotubes (CNTs) are hollow cylindrical structures of graphene sheets [9]. CNTs are classified as Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes (SWCNTs) and Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes (MWCNTs) [10]. CNTs, in combination with the drugs like doxorubicin, are used extensively as improving agents in cancer therapy and diagnosis because of their large surface area, conjugation ability, and encapsulation of drugs [11,12]. To make CNTs tumor-specific, they can be conjugated with ligands against biomarkers that are over-expressed in cancerous tissues. For example SWCNTs can be conjugated with CD44 antibodies to target CD44 receptors on breast cancer stem cells [13]. Although CNTs are hydrophobic in nature, they can be functionalized with hydrophilic substances to improve their biocompatibility and solubility [9]. Because of their unique physiochemical properties, CNTs have numerous applications in diagnosis and treatment of different diseases especially cancer [11]. Chemotherapeutic drugs are encapsulated in nano-scale devices to increase the targeted drug delivery and bioavailability of breast cancer drugs [14]. Nanomaterials are nano-carriers of drugs; having the ability of imaging, tracking, and targeting [9].

Nanoparticle is a nanomedicine for cancer treatment and it has been reported by researchers that the uptake of nanoparticles (organic or inorganic) can improve the limitations of traditional therapeutics [15]. Particles having size between 1 and 100 nm are referred as nanoparticle [16]. Basically nanoparticles (NPs) are involved in targeted drug delivery at the tumor site. Microparticles cannot pass through tiny capillaries having 5-6 microns diameter, so nanoparticle are more suitable to reach remote areas at cancer site [17].

Drug carriers are of several types such as micelles, polymeric dendrimers, microspheres, quantum dots (QDs), nanoemulsions, liposomes, hydrogels, and gold nanoparticle (GNPs), which adopt diverse methods of drug attachment such as covalent binding, adsorption, and encapsulation [14]. Gold Nanoparticle are considered as a best vaccine vector because they have appropriate payload and are highly biocompatible [16]. Systematic administration of nanoparticle at the tumor site causes accumulation of nanoparticle in the tumor cells through Enhanced Permeability and Retention (EPR) effect, this is due to poor drainage of lymphatic system [18].

Literature Review

In cancer therapy nano-medicines face certain obstacles in becoming a new paradigm due to incomplete understanding of nano-bio interactions, complexities, heterogeneity of tumor biology, chemistry and Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP). Difference between the efficacies obtained in preclinical studies and the outcomes from clinical trials, is another well recognized obstacle due to lack of tumor models that can recapitulate human cancers [19]. Enhanced Permeability and Retention effect (EPR) is one of the example in which small animal models show positive results but such evidences are lacking in humans during clinical trials [20]. In vivo and in vitro toxicity testing assays show that nonomaterials have detrimental effects to biological system at molecular and cellular level because of varying physiochemical properties as, these can impact numerous biological pathways. Because it is impossible to study toxicological properties of all Nano material variants, it is a challenge to testing toxicity of nanomaterials (Figure 1) [21].

Keloid

Figure 1: Keloid demonstrating a nodular, erythematous, elongated, raised lesion confined to the hand [12].

Carbon nanotubes in breast cancer treatment

The promising size, needle-like structure and unique physiochemical properties of carbon nanotubes make them a good tool for fighting breast cancer [9]. CNTs are mostly used for targeted drug delivery and photothermal therpy for breast cancer [11].

One of the major causes of treatment resistance in breast cancer is hypoxia. This is because tumor cells initiate multiple adaptation processes under hypoxic conditions which results in treatment failure. In 2017, Jia, Weng et al. determined the increase in chemosensitivity and radiosensitivity of MDA MB 231 and ZR 75 1 human breast cancer cell lines by synthesizing a new functionalized single walled carbon nanotube carrying oxygen. They synthesized an oxygen carrying tombarthite modified folic acid conjugated chitosan (R O2 FA CHI) SWCNT nanocarrier and treated cancer cell lines with this nanocarrier along with chemotherapy drugs or radiotherpy. It was observed that the R O2 FA CHI SWCNTs significantly enhanced the chemosensitivity and radiosensitivity of human breast cancer cell lines by downregulating the expression of B cell lymphoma 2 (Bcl 2), survivin, hypoxia inducible factor 1 α (HIF 1α), multidrug resistance associated protein 1 (MRP 1), P glycoprotein (P gp), RAD51 and Ku80 [22].

Targeted drug delivery

In order to make carbon naotubes tumor-specific, they can be conjugated with monoclonal antibodies (mAb) or aptamers [10]. In 2015, Al Faraj, Shaik et al. determined the efficiency of SWCNTs to improve the clinical utilty of doxorubicin (DOX) in breast cancer murine model. They synthesized Iron-tagged SWCNTs conjugated with Endoglin/CD105 antibody with or without DOX. After characterizing the nanoparticles for biocompatibilty, they were actively and magnetically targeted to tumor sites in murine model. It was observed that DOX-loaded SWCNTs induced significant increases in apoptosis, DNA damage, and oxidative stress. These results showed enhanced therapeutic efficacy of DOX delivered through antibody-conjugated magnetic SWCNTs [23].

Another approach to control the cancer cell proliferation and metasis to other tissues is by blocking certain molecular pathways through small molecules or monoclonal antibody. Trastumzumab an anti-HER monoclonal antibody is considred to be the best targeted therapy so far. The nanodelivery of trastuzumab can be done by decorating the surfaces of nanocarriers with antibody and allowing targeted delivery of trastuzumab to HER2+ cells. Antibody conjugated with gold sulfide nanoparticles can be used for photoablation terapy and ln-labeled trastuzumab conjugated to modified gold nanoparticles can be used for radiation therapy [24].

Abraxane, also called as nab-paclitaxel or nanoparticle albumin bound paclitexal, is another example of targeted drug delivery to breast cancer cells [24]. Paclitaxel (PTX) has been an important contribution to the treatment o f breast cancer. A single walled carbon nanotube based drug delivery system (SWNT-HAS) was established using human albumin proteins. This combination displayed 80% of intracellular drug delivery in MCF-7 breast cancer cell along with high growth inhibition; suggesting high delivery efficiency and effectiveness [25].

A cisplatin modified poly(d,1-lactide-co-glycolide) (PLGA) has shown significant efficacy in breast cancer patients [14].

Photothermal therapy

Because of the intrinsic hyperthermic property of CNTs induced by near-infrared (NIR) irradiation, several attempts have been made to use them for the photothermal ablation of cancer cells [26]. In 2016, Han, Han et al. synthesized SWCNTs conjugated with PEG and thioaptamer and determined their effect in human breast cancer targeted photothermal therapy in-vivo and invitro. In vivo testing was performed via injection to the caudal vein to subcutaneous breast cancer mice models while HCC1937 human breast cancer cells were used for in vitro testing. In vitro results showed that SWCNT-PEG-TA significantly decreased the cell viability. Similar results were observed in in vivo study as well [27]. In another study carried out by Oh, Jin et al. in 2017, MDAMB- 231 cell death promoted by SWCNTs-Dox was investigated. Dox-release from SWCNTs was accelerated by NIR irradiation. It was observed that Dox released from SWNTs-Dox effectively localized into the MDA-MB-231 cell nucleus and accumulated inside the cells at high concentration. SWNTs-Dox and PPT together promoted an effective cell death in MDA-MB-231 cells by mitochondrial disruption and Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS) generation [28].

Nanoparticles an emerging nanomaterial to treat breast cancer

Conventional chemotherapeutics have systemic toxicity and adverse effects on normal cells. Nanotechnology has revolutionized the treatment of breast cancer by targeted drug delivery. Nanoparticles have some important parameters such as size, charge, and shape. These parameters are significant in targeted drug delivery at cancer site. There are many advantages concerned with nanoparticles: (1) prevention of early degradation of drug, (2) absorption rate of drug is increased in selected tumor areas, (3) intracellular penetration of drug is increased by nanosystem, (4) lowers the rate of systemic toxicity, (5) premature interaction of drug and biological system is inhibited, (6) have capacity to absorb or load more than one therapeutic drugs, (7) nanomedicines are more stable as compared to conventional ones. So nanomedicines are easily accessible to tumor site and have great potential to treat cancer [29,30].

Nanoscale dispersions of solid particles are referred as nanoparticles. According to American society for Testing and Materials, nanoparticles are three dimensional small bits of matter, having size from 1-100 nm [31]. Nanoparticle are classified into different types; nanospheres, nanorings, nanoshells, nanocapsules, fullerenes, liposomes, dendrimers and quantum dots [32].

Cancer treatment by nano-system

Tumor is optimally treated by using nanoparticles (NPs), either organic or inorganic in nature. Organic nanoparticles are composed of organic and inorganic materials. Nanoparticles are made from components of particular metals having specific physicochemical properties and these properties are related to that particular metal [15].

Abraxane is nanoparticle based medicine used to treat breast cancer, approved by Food and Drug Administration in 2005 [33].

Inorganic nanoparticles

Inorganic nanoparticles are made up of two basic parts: shell and core. Core of inorganic NP is made up of metals such as gold, silver, quantum dots, and iron oxides. Shell is composed of either organic polymers or metals. The function of shell is to protect the inner core from chemical interactions and act as a binding substrate for biomolecules [15].

Gold nanoparticle

Gold nanoparticles are highly selective anti-cancerous nanodrugs having unique biological compatibility, and increased payload efficiency. Various biomolecules are coated over gold nanoparticles to make their surface functionalized and more stable in biological environment. Gold nanoparticles are pharmaceutical cargos for targeted drug delivery at tumor site [34].

Characteristics of gold nanoparticles

Gold nanoparticles are found in different sizes, shapes, compositions, and structures. Gold nanospheres (AuNPs) are solid gold balls which are synthesized by the reduction of chloroauric acid, having diameter from few to more than 100 nm. Gold nanoshells (AuNSs) are composed of silica cores and thin gold shells protecting that silica cores, having size between 50-150 nm. [31]. Inorganic Nanoparticle such as nanoshells and GNPs are used in combination with MIR and high-resolution superconducting quantum interference devices to enhance the therapeutic effect [35].

Gold nanoparticles conjugated with trastuzumab increases the uptake of AuNPs by breast cancer cells and trastuzumab conjugated AuNPs is potentially strong therapeutic agent to treat breast cancer (Figure 2) [31].

nanoparticles

Figure 2: AuNPs (gold nanoparticles) to treat/kill breast cancer. (a) Normal amount of HER2 in normal breast cell. HER2 Receptors sending signals to breast cell to grow and divide in normal fashion as in mitotic cell division. (b) Huge amount of HER2+ in cancerous breast cell. Too much HER2 receptors sending more signals, causing cell to grow and divide quickly in uncontrolled manner by losing mitotic mechanism. (c) Trastuzumab (antibody) is chemically conjugated with AuNP (gold nanoparticle) via a protein called a linker molecule. Transtuzumab is used to treat breast cancer that is HER2 receptor positive, where AuNP has a huge payload efficiency. (d) Gold nanoparticle is pharmaceutical cargo and able to transport drug at targeted tumor sitr and thus blocking the HER2+ receptors from signalling the cell to divide and grow in uncontrolled manner.

Quantum Dots (QDs)

Nanocrystals, inorganic in nature, 1-10 nm in diameter having properties of semiconductor are called quantum dots (QDs). Group II-VI or groups III-V elements of periodic table are concerned with synthesis of QDs. CdSe nanoparticles are quantum dots. CdSe acts as a core of QDs and shell is made up of another semiconductor, usually ZnS acts as a shell [36].

QDs can load large amount of drug, we can say they offer large payload without altering the properties of therapeutic agents [15]. QDs are beneficial and attractive in biological imaging, cancer diagnosis and treatment because they can emit fluorescent when subjected to an energy source. QDs are highly photo stable for longer period because of their amazing surface composition. In breast cancer research QDs are used for the purpose of targeted drug delivery. Limitation associated with QDs is toxicity and excretion pathway of drug. Elements that are involved in the composition of QDs make them either toxic or non-toxic. Cadmium causes toxicity of QDots. Sometimes high dose of QDs cause alteration in nucleus and mitochondria of the cell thus leading to the cell death and toxicity [9].

Organic nanoparticles

Liposomes nanoparticles: Spherical vesicles of hydrophilic or hydrophobic in nature having bilayer membranous structures are called liposomes. Single lipid bilayer liposomes have watery core for entrapping hydrophilic drugs, but liposomes having multi lipid bilayer, encapsulate lipid soluble drugs. PlasmidDNA and siRNA are efficiently encapsulated in the hydrophobic core of liposomes based Nanoparticle [15]. Liposomes differ in size from 50-100 nm and can aggregate in cancer cells. Liposomes are categorized into different types based on their structure, size, wetness of surface, and preparation methods [14].

Drug delivery system comprised of liposomes is significant in biodistribution of drugs by improving the pharmacological structures and properties of traditional chemotherapeutic drugs. Liposome based cancer drugs have overcome the limitations of toxic drugs. Now-a-days, different methods are used to load nanomedicines on lipid-based system. Liposomes are excellent carriers to load anticancer drugs because of their unique pharmacological structure. Liposomes reduce the toxicity of conventional drugs by changing the biodistribution of encapsulated drug [37].

Paclitaxel (LEP-ETU/Insys) is loaded on liposomes and is used to treat phase II of breast cancer whereas Doxorubicin (Myocettm/ Teva UK) has been approved to treat metastatic breast cancer [29]. Liposomal anthracycline has an active anticancer agent to treat breast cancer [38].

Dendrimers

Polymers having nanoscale branched system are dendrimers. “Dendron” is a Greek word and meaning is tree like. Dendrimers are unique structures synthesized from monomers by step growth polymerization technique having stability and uniformity in branching system. Three main regions of dendrimers are surface, complex branching system, and the core molecule in the central region of the dendrimer. Dendrimers are categorized based on branches, dendrimer having only one branch, or one core molecule is called generation 0 (G0) dendrimer. Addition of one more branch to existing core of dendrimers is called generation 1 (G1) dendrimer. The continuous and successive addition of branches in the dendrimer structure form G2, G3, G4 and so on. Dendrimers have bigger diameter because of complex and enhanced branching system [39,40].

Due to stable structure they are best nano drug carriers. Anticancer drugs are either encapsulated in the dendrimers or stick to the dendrimers by forming complex structure. Branched structure of dendrimersis involved in drug delivery as well as gene delivery. Dendrimers usually attach to polyamidoamine (PAMAM), poly (ethylene glycol) (PEG), chitin and chitosan [33].

Bio-inspired virus nanoparticles

Natural biomaterials that are biodegradable and bio-suitable are virus nanoparticles (VNPs). VNPs consist of self-assembling and self-proliferative system. Viral nanoparticles reproduce many times in a short time span but maintaining their symmetry throughout proliferating activity. Potato virus X (PVX) having size of 515 × 12 nm is most popular viral nanoparticles. Plant viral nanoparticles (VNPs) have many applications in nanobiotechnology. Most common application of VNPs is targeted drug delivery and has ability to surround cancer cells by penetrating and homing tumor. Herceptin (HER) is delivered via PVX by conjugating with Herceptin (PVX-HER) to kill cell lines involved in two types of breast cancers [41,42].

Discussion

Obstacles

Carbon nano materials used to treat breast cancer, in their native form are insoluble in biological aqueous environment and these lack the molecular aggregates to provide specific activities, leading to their excessive accumulation in body and hinder their elimination from body [43]. Nano carriers used for target drug delivery purposes, still have limited therapeutic benefits because of physiochemical barriers such as tumor penetration, tumor heterogeneity, relative hypoxia, and endosomalescape [44].

Doxorubicin (DOX) is a broad-spectrum anticancer drug used to treat breast cancer. Because of low therapeutic index and life its high dose is required, which cause some unwanted results to normal tissues and induce cumulative cardiac toxicity [12]. By using nanotechnology PEGylated liposomal doxorubicin (Doxil) formulated, and used to treat breast cancer [45]. Pegylated liposomal doxorubicin (PLD) improve the efficacy and lower the side effects of Doxorubicin as it has different pharmacokinetics profile. Through a consistent review of phase II clinical trials the side effects of PLD in metastatic breast cancer was studied [46]. Doxil limits the cardiotoxicity but resulted to another side effects because of high concentration accumulation in skin. Skin eruptions which were encountered are hand-foot syndrome, diffuse follicular rash, intertrigo like eruption, and new formation of melanotic macules. Thus, to identifying a right nanoparticle is crucial as an effort used to solve one problem can leads to another issue [45].

Raw carbon nanotubes and functionalized multi wall Carbon nanotubes have cytotoxicity potential in human breast cancer cells (MCF-7) but they also show adverse effects to human health [47]. Their small size and high surface area lead to increase their chemical reactivity and induce changes to permeability to biological membrane [48]. Due to which they induce health risks because they can reach to every part of tissue, organ and can interact with cellular metabolic pathways to cause adverse effects [47].

Some of the nanoparticles have cytotoxicity effects because of their non-specific activity, can damage to normal replicating cells. Trustuzumab and pertuzumab used to treat breast cancer but on other hand also heart related problems was showed in women. Tamoxifen also have serious side effects as increased 1.9 times thromboembolic disease and 2.4 times endomaterial cancer chances in a woman of 50 years or older. Therefore, for treatment of breast cancer selective delivery of cytotoxic nanoparticles to tumor cells and to keep the efficacy-toxicity balance is critical [49].

Due to certain problems there are some nanoparticles which are restricted to use, like magnetic nanoparticles, Quantum dots and Carbon nanotubes have potential material toxicity and solid lipid nanoparticles have low capacity to load drugs and these all still have no clinical trials. Polymeric nanocarrier leads to degradation of carrier and go through to only phase 1 clinical trials e.g. paclitaxel [24].

For targeted drug delivery purposes, the complex formulation of nanomaterials is required, which increased the risks of toxicity, immunogenicity, higher production cost, and good manufacturing practice issues. Breast cancer is more fatal and destructive when metastasis occurs, and it spread to other parts of body like brain, bone, lung, liver. So such nanomedicines need to develop which can percolate to these site without causing any side effects [24].

Another challenge related to nanoparticles is their effects to environment. During formation these nanoparticles require the special precautions as airborne nanoparticles can spread into environment as aerosol. Which can lead to lungs deposition to cause pulmonary diseases. Similarly, some nanoparticles can penetrate skin barrier to cause dermatological problems [45,50].

Conclusion

Breast cancer is being studied extensively to design new drugs and methods for treatment, and nanotechnology has brought tremendous advancements in treatment methods. Nanomaterials provide numerous functionalization options from conjugation with anti-breast cancer antibodies to surface modifications for enhanced drug delivery. Although several techniques have been developed, there is a room for more research to fully understand the capabilities and potential of the nanomaterial to further advance the treatment methods and minimize the toxicity issues. The absence of human tumor models presents an ongoing problem in the advancement of nanotechnological approaches. Currently there have not been many clinical studies regarding the use of nanomaterials in breast cancer treatment due to toxicity problems but many studies showed that the future seems bright for the nanomedicine in breast cancer treatment.

References

Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language

Viewing options

Flyer image

Share This Article