Metal Complexes of Nicotine: A Group of Negligible Compounds

Ahmed E Fazary*

Chemistry Department, Faculty of Science, King Khalid University, Abha 9004, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Applied Research Sector, Egyptian Organization for Biological Products and Vaccines (VACSERA Holding Company), 51 Wezaret El-Zeraa St., Agouza, Giza, Egypt

Corresponding Author:
Ahmed E Fazary
Chemistry Department, Faculty of Science
King Khalid University, Abha 9004, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
Applied Research Sector, Egyptian Organization for Biological Products and Vaccines (VACSERA Holding Company)
51 Wezaret El-Zeraa St., Agouza, Giza, Egypt
 
Visit for more related articles at Der Chemica Sinica

Abstract

Nicotine (NIC) is an oxygenic alkaloid compound exists in two forms R and S, and consists of a pyridine ring, substituted at the 3-position with an N-methyl-pyrrolidine ring. Nicotine is extracted mostly from the Nicotiana tabacum plant, and although it was made in the roots and accumulates in smaller amounts in leaves of edible plants of the nightshade family called “Solanaceae’’ such as tomatoes, potatoes, green peppers, and coca plants. Biochemically, it’s parasympathomimetic, stimulant drug, and is a nicotinic acetylcholine receptor agonist. It functions as an antiherbivore, insecticide, imidacloprid, and recently chromatin-modifying enzymes inhibitor. Nicotine was considered to be one of the most biologically important compounds, for which information about their metal ions complexation properties are very rare in the literature. However, recently it gains much attention from many bioinorganic chemists over the world. In the present mini review article, I described the research done during the last few decades about the solid chemistry of nicotine and studies concerning a number of crystal structures of nicotine complexes. Also, I reported about the rare research work done previously about the protonation and complexation equilibria studies of nicotine in which the data of the different equilibrium constants and stability constants of nicotine would be valued in metal based drug research.

image

Graphical Abstract: Molecular Structure of Nicotine ((S)/(R)-3-(1-Methylpyrrolidine-2-yl) pyridine, NIC).

Keywords

Nicotine; Metal complexes; Solution equilibrium; Crystal structures

Introduction

In coordination and bioinorganic chemistry, one of the most important modules of bio ligands is the nitrogen heterocyclic compounds [1]. The most widely studied of these compounds are sex membered heterocycles such as nitrogen pyridine, 2,2’-bipyridine and 2,2’:6’,2”-terpyridine [1,2] (Scheme 1). Other related ligands that have been extensively employed in inorganic chemistry are the five membered nitrogen heterocycles such as pyrazole and imidazole compounds [1,2] (Scheme 1).

der-chemica-sinica-Molecular-structures

Scheme 1: Molecular structures of main known nitrogen heterocyclic compounds.

Due to the interactions between the μ* antibonding orbitals of the nitrogen ligand and the d-orbitals of a metal ion, strong coordinate bonds are mostly formed, resulting in a stable metal complexes [3]. The incorporation of two or more of these donor ligands into a single molecule can result in species which can bridge between two metal centres, chelate to a single metal centre, or a combination of both these motifs. Chelation to a metal centre increases the stability of the complex, and so is desirable for inclusion into the design of bio ligands. The bridging of metal centres by a ligand can result in connection between the metal ion centres, as well as resulting in higher order molecular architectures including discrete molecular species, such as molecular squares, cubes and cages (Scheme 2), and polymeric molecular species (Scheme 3) such as chains, ladders, helicates and metal-organic frameworks [4].

der-chemica-sinica-topological-motifs

Scheme 2: Most frequently observed topological motifs in discrete molecular species (small grey spheres) and metal node (large grey sphere): (a) square, (b) cube, and (c) cage.

der-chemica-sinica-polymeric-molecular

Scheme 3: Most frequently observed topological motifs in polymeric molecular species: (a)linearchain, (b)zig-zag chain, (c) ladder, (d)helicates, and (e) metal-organic framework.

Our concern in this article is nicotine which consists of a pyridine ring, substituted at the 3-position with an N-methylpyrrolidine ring (Scheme 4) [5]. Nicotine is extracted from the Nicotiana tabacum plant (Figure 1), although it is found in smaller amounts amongst other plants of the Solanaceae family [5].

der-chemica-sinica-computer-generated

Scheme 4: Molecular structure of nicotine ((S)/(R)-3-(1-methylpyrrolidine-2-yl) pyridine, NIC) and its computer-generated

der-chemica-sinica-Nicotiana-tabacum

Figure 1: Nicotiana tabacum plant.

Bioinorganic Chemistry of Nicotine Metal Complexes

Previous work on the bioinorganic chemistry of nicotine has been limited to a few studies, and only a few number of crystal structures of nicotine complexes have been reported. Original work on the solid chemistry of nicotine metal complexes was carried out to investigate the synthesis of various nicotine metal salts called “double salts” [6]. Most of these complexes have been synthesized and their three-dimensional structures were elucidated using single crystal X-ray crystallography technique.

By looking to the literature, we found only a few numbers of studies about the organic and inorganic chemistry of nicotine and its derivatives. Most of the organic chemistry studies reports about the synthesis of new substituted nicotine derivatives and analogues due to their pharmacological applications as potential chiral coordination ligands [7-19]. Three crystal structures of metal complexes of nicotine had been previously [20-23]. In these reports, the first crystal structure of a mercuric complex of nicotine was determined [23] describing a structure in which nicotine acts as a bridging ligand between tetrahedral Hg(II) centres, forming a one-dimensional coordination polymer. Then, a detailed crystal structures of a complexes in which four nicotine molecules are coordinated to copper [24], silver(I) [25] and zirconium [26] were investigated. In these structures nicotine acts a monodentate ligand, coordinated via the pyridine nitrogen. Followed by a report about three nicotine complexes, each one of them consist of a lanthanide metal bonded to three indenyl ligands and a single, pyridine linked, nicotine molecule [27]. These previous X-ray crystal structures indicates that only two of the possible three bonding modes of nicotine have been observed; coordination of the pyridine nitrogen, and coordination of both the pyridine and pyrrolidinenitrogens, where the nicotine molecule acts as a bridging ligand.

Reactions of zinc(II) chloride with (S)-(-)-nicotine yielded new metal complex, which was characterized by elemental analysis, infrared, single crystal X-ray diffraction 13C and 1H NMR spectral methods [28]. Quantum chemical calculations indicate that in the isolated state the anti-conformation of the uncoordinated chalcogen nicotine lactams is slightly more preferred energetically and it does not undergo substantial changes upon coordination to the metal center (Figure 2). The preference for the syn conformation in crystals of thio- and selenolactams of nicotine might be ascribed to their involvement in columnar stacking interactions, which do not operate in the isolated state [28]. This study has provided useful information regarding functionalization of (S)-(-)-nicotine molecule as a mixed-donor-atom ligand to enforce formation of 1D coordination polymers [28].

der-chemica-sinica-selenolactam-molecules

Figure 2: Conformations of (a) S)-nicotine lactam, thiolactam and selenolactam molecules, and (b) (S)-nicotine thiolactam and selenolactam molecules [28].

A metal complex derivative from a coumarin bearing a porphyrin unit was spectroscopically characterized and its sensing ability towards the alkaloids nicotine was evaluated [29]. Both solid state and solution chemistry of copper(II)-nicotine complexes have been reported [30,31]. The quantum-mechanical calculations helped elucidate the experimental data as they provided some information on the energetic of the possible interaction modes of Cu(II) with nicotine (Figure 3). The studies showed that nicotine acts as a monodentate ligand utilizing for this purpose the pyridine nitrogen atom [30,31]. A number of chiral methacrylate copper (II), zinc (II), metal complexes of (S)-(-)- nicotine have been studied and their X-ray crystal structures established to investigate the possibility of chirality being transferred from the respective metal complexes to the backbone of the derived copolymers, the chiral metal complex template having previously been cleaved and removed [32].

der-chemica-sinica-crystal-structure

Figure 3: Copper(II) - nicotine crystal structure [31]

The monoclinic crystal structure of tetraaquabis(ethylisonicotinate)cobalt(II) disaccharinate complex has been determined by X-ray diffraction analysis at room temperature in three mutually perpendicular planes [33]. This complex presents a slightly distorted octahedral environment, with equatorially coordinated water molecules and axially pyridine N-bound ethylisonicotinate ligands [33]. The magnetic environments of the complex have been identified by electron paramagnetic resonance technique. The cyclic voltammogram of the studied complex investigated in dimethylformamide solution exhibits only metal centerdelectroactivity in the potential range -1.0-1.25 V versus Ag/AgCl reference electrode [33]. Mono and bis-zinc(II)-centered salphen derivatives are studied as efficient adsorption materials for nicotine derivatives using X-ray analysis and UV-vis, NMR spectroscopic methods, as well the high binding constants of the supramolecular complexes based on nicotine were additionally determined. X-ray analyses [34]. The influence of Pt(IV) metal complexes involving substituted nicotinamides and isonicotinamides on the activity of cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) phosphodiesterase was studied, whereas substituted nicotine amides are inhibitors of enzymatic cAMP phosphodiesterase activity [35].

Three copper(II) coordination polymers involving nicotinato anion as a bridging ligand and 2,2′-bipyridine or dicyanamide as coligands [36]. The copper metal-nicotine ligand association in these complexes is very similar and generates tubelike coordination polymers, which are constructed from pairs of copper atoms connected through two carboxylato groups from two nicotinate ligands [36]. Each pyridyl moiety from the nicotine-ligand coordinates at the apical position of the copper ions from another pair, resulting in chains running along the crystallographic c axis [36]. The cryomagnetic investigation of the three copper(II) coordination polymers reveals weak antiferromagnetic interactions mediated by the nicotinato ligand [36]. Anumber of tridentate monoanion or tridentate dianionacetoacetanilide isonicotinylhydrazone and its metal chelates were synthesized and characterized mainly by elemental analysis; conductivity measurements; and electronic, infrared, and nuclear magnetic resonance spectral studies [36].

These compounds were found to exhibited anticancer activity and revealed that they are active against pathogenic fungal strains, and the chelates were found to be more active than the ligand [37]. A self-assembled structural analysis of binuclear square pyramidal new 3-D neutral copper(II)-multidentatenicotinato organic framework coordination polymer was reported [38]. A family of three ferrimagnetic manganese(II) complexes involving N,N′-dimethylnicotinium ligand were synthesized and characterized [39]. The use of high temperature expansion of the partition function and molecular mean field approach showing that these compounds adopt a two-dimensional structure [39].

Novel metal La(II), Pr(III), and Nd(IV) complexes of nicotine were synthesized and their chemical structures were exhaustively characterized using X-ray diffraction, circular dichroism, and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic methods [40]. The chiral carbon atom of nicotine lies approximately twice as far from the metal centre than the chiral sulfur atom of the methyl tolylsulfoxide ligand in the previously reported lanthanums-methyl tolylsulfoxide complexes [40]. A strong intramolecular antiferromagnetic dodecylnicotinatebis-adducts of binuclear copper carboxylates were synthesized and their crystal structure, thermal behavior and magnetic properties were studied [41]. The dimer is centrosymmetric with the copper(II) ions in a square-pyramidal coordination with four O-alkyl O atoms in the basal plane and the nicotine N atom at apical positions, and the copper(II) ions are bridged by four O-alkyl carboxylate groups [42]. The stoichiometric complexation of palladium(II) or mercury(II) ions with 6-Pyridylnicotine and bis-6,6'- nicotine were also studied [42].

Conformational analysis and steric effect of nicotine-transition metal complexes models were used to rationalize the structure and some stereospecific reactions that these complexes undergo [43]. Two different steric models are presented which correlate the rate of N-alkylation of alkyl-substituted pyridines and quinolines as well as acyclic amines and cyclic nonaromatic amines using molecular mechanics/molecular orbital derived steric energies [44]. The stereoselectivities of methylation of conformationally mobile nicotine analogs are examined with regard to steric and electronic effects. The Curtin-Hammett principle and the Winstein-Holness equation allow quantitative analysis of the kinetics [43]. Zinc(II) complexation with pure nicotine was used in a simple, economical and quick method for extraction of pure nicotine from Nicotiana tabacum and subsequent removal of the metal as ZnS [44].

The effect of various Lewis acids such as SbCl5, SnCl4, SbCl3, AlI3, FeCl3, AlBr3, AlCl3, TiCl4, ZnCl2, HgCl2, CdCl2 on the optical rotatory power of nicotine has been meausred in dimethylformamide or in toluene [45]. The increment of optical rotation of nicotine by the action of most Lewis acids and the difference between the specific rotation of free nicotine and that of nicotine co-ordinated to Lewis acid decreases [45]. A number of complex metal-nicotine species were studied and estimated. The compounds have been characterized, and their plausible structures have been suggested for all these complexes based on the elemental analyses, magnetic measurements, X-ray crystal, electron spin resonance and infrared spectral studies (Figure 4) [6,7,46,47].

der-chemica-sinica-Ruthenium

Figure 4: Ruthenium(III) and iridium(III) crystal structures with nicotine [47]

Solution Chemistry of Nicotine Metal Complexes

Recently, in July 2016, it has been reported about the chemical investigation of the interaction mechanisms of nicotine with some divalent metal ions such as Pb2+, Fe2+, and Cu2+. The complex formation equilibria between nicotine and these metal ions have been investigated at room temperature, in solutions using UV/Vis spectrophotometric and potentiometric techniques. The protolysis constants of nicotine have been determined and evaluated under the same experimental conditions. Using the specific ion interaction theory, the conditional acid constants of nicotine have been deduced in zero ionic strength solutions. The experimental results of the graphical and numerical methods adopted indicated the formation of predominating nicotine mononuclear complexes.

Lastly, the protonation and metal complex formation equilibrium constants of nicotine with trivalent and divalent metal ions have been investigated in water solutions using pH-potentiometric and cyclic voltammetry techniques. Also, the dissociation constants of NIC and the equilibrium constants of its binary complexes with the studied metal ions in water solutions were observed at different temperatures. From the experimental stability constants of different metal-nicotine complex species, the concentration distribution diagrams of the various metal ions - nicotine complex species in solutions were also estimated using HySS 2009 software.

Conclusion and Recommendations

It was shown that divalent and trivalent metal ions complexes of nicotine were stable in both solution and solid forms. The observed order of stability of the nicotine complex systems is trivalent metal complex ions>divalent metal complex ions. The formation of the binary NIC complex was found to be spontaneous and exothermic. The stability constants and synthesis of the complexes between nicotine and essential metal ions were studied to investigate the complexation behavior of these systems as it could mimic many biological interactions of the. The complexes appear to be superior in biological properties to ligand alone. The complexes were found to increase the cytotoxic, antioxidant, and antimicrobial activity of the pure ligand which is probably related to the enhancement of hydrophobicity of the synthesized compounds. The stability constant determination was focused on mono-nuclear (single metal) complexes. Further investigation involving poly-nuclear complexes is suggested in order to understand the distribution of complexes in physiological pH condition. In this review, the nicotine ligand is monomer. The used of polymer ligand will be interesting and their macromolecular complexes might be able to improve more biological properties.

Acknowledgement

This work was supported by King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology (KACST), Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, under Grant MS-35-73.

References

Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language

Viewing options

Post your comment

Share This Article

Recommended Conferences

  • 4th European Organic Chemistry CongressMarch 01-03, London, UK
  • 4thInternational Conference on Glycobiology and GlycochemistryMay 16-17, Singapore
  • 3rd International Conference on Food Chemistry & NutritionMay 16-18, Montreal, Canada
  • 6th International Conference and Exhibition on Materials Science and ChemistryMay 17-18, Rome, Italy
  • 17th International Conference on Industrial Chemistry and Water TreatmentMay 21-22, New York, USA
Flyer image
journal indexing image
 

Post your comment

captcha   Reload  Can't read the image? click here to refresh